Was the south doomed to lose the civil war

was the south doomed to lose the civil war A comparison of the south's experience with defeat and america's emerging response to its loss of the war in vietnam may be helpful such a comparison need not ignore the substantial differences between the civil and vietnam wars the former was a domestic conflict, fought only on american soil.

Was the confederacy doomed to failure historian jim mcintyre says, yes, and he intends to tell us why in this lecture on military strategy during the us civil war this event was hosted in the moraine valley community college library as part of the one book, one college program. How the south could have won the civil war by bevin alexander provides a startling account of how a relatively small number of tactical and strategic mistakes cost the south the war-and changed the failure to recognize the realities facing the south and disagreement over strategy are what doomed the confederacy. So we decided to ask ten of the country's most respected civil war historians: “ why did the south lose the civil war” here (edited for length) are their answers –carl zebrowski william c davis former editor of civil war times illustrated and author of more than thirty books about the war, including the recent a. His latest book is “their last full measure: the final days of the civil war” (2015 ) from a distance of 150 years, the union victory in the civil war may appear to have been inevitable, and the south's attempt to achieve sovereignty doomed from the start this story line has much to recommend it the north. We have been told endlessly that the us civil war was a good war, fought to free the slaves about 110100 union although slavery had been around for thousands of years, abolitionists launched epic movements generating political support that doomed slavery in only about a century and a quarter. An extensive amount of effort has gone into studying the american civil war the reasons while the defeat at gettysburg is cited as the reason why the south lost the war, many arguments are provided as to why the confederates lost that battle some have they had less to lose by being in the union. I agree with the idea that the north had won the civil war before it began to the extent of lincoln's conservative political stands trying to (why did the confederacy lose, pg 117)the south really enjoyed mcclellan's performance in the southern theatre with his tendency to retreat when he could have won this was.

Many of these workers advocated british intervention on behalf of the south to restore the cotton supplies but their political impotence, the increasing supplies of cotton from egypt, and the growing realization that the south would lose the war doomed their efforts as the war went on, even southerners found the embargo too. The american civil war (also known by other names) was a civil war that was fought in the united states from 1861 to 1865 as a result of the long-standing controversy over slavery, war broke out in april 1861, when confederate forces attacked fort sumter in south carolina, shortly after us president abraham lincoln. But how did monuments to the losing side in america's civil war become such an intense focus for a national white-supremacist movement mostly, though not exclusively, those statues can be found in those southern states that broke from the union in 1861 over their desire to retain the system of slavery.

However some of the south's military errors could have cost them the war for example, it has been argued that whilst the south was tactically good, their generals did not match the union ones such as grant and sherman robert e lee has been criticised for losing the west-and therefore the war- for the confederacy,. If positioned northwest of washington, lee could force the federals to remain between him and their capital, thus liberating war-exhausted northern and north- central virginia, as well as the shenandoah valley, from the presence of the contending armies southern farms that had suffered from the presence of scores of. Learn about the political, social, and economic changes in the union and the confederacy and the civil war's long-term economic and intellectual impact wartime leadership, internal dissent in both the north and south, the changing position of women in both societies, and the war's long-term economic.

During the american civil war, the confederate president made several decisions that led to the defeat of the south add that with other poor choices such as polk, the western theater was practically doomed davis was too slow in responding to in wanting to protect all, he risked losing it all sentiment. This is a slim book (approximately 124 pages) that contains essays by different writers who each examine a major factor that contributed to the south losing the civil war although in hindsight it appears that the south was doomed to lose, in reality, it was a close contest that literally could have been won by either side. Many consider july 4, 1863 to be the turning point of the american civil war two important, famous, well-documented battles resulted in confederate defeats: the battle of gettysburg (pennsylvania), july 1-3, and the fall of vicksburg ( mississippi), july 4 however, two other major, lesser-known events.

Was the south doomed to lose the civil war

Although the reasons for the defeat of the confederacy in the american civil war are debated just as energetically as the causes of the war, the answer to the question, “why did the south lose the war” was actually answered a long time ago. “this lincoln always publicly condemned the abolitionists who fought slavery by extra constitutional means – and condemned also the mobs who deprived them of their right of free as the civil war came underway the south's military, smaller than the north's, would take heavy blows from the decisions of the confederacy.

  • Mcpherson summarises this rationalisation of the confederate position as: “the south did not lose confederates wore themselves out whipping the yankees and collapsed from glorious exhaustion”4 1 mcpherson james m, “drawn with the sword – reflections on the american civil war”: new york oxford university.
  • Symbols of the confederacy are an inescapable fact of life in southern states the confederate flag is displayed prominently near the south carolina statehouse, evoked in multiple southern state flags, flown in frontyards, on t- shirts and off pickup trucks and those who fought during the civil war to.
  • By itself, the south's economic investment in slavery could easily explain the willingness of southerners to risk war when faced with what they viewed as a serious with so much to lose on both sides of the mason-dixon line, economic logic suggests that a peaceful solution to the slave issue would have made far more.

By march 1865, it was obvious to all but the most die-hard confederates that the south was going to lose the war whether that loss was inevitable is an unanswerable question, but considering various “what if” scenarios has long been a popular exercise among historians, novelists and civil war buffs. To answer trump's question on the civil war, this is from joy hakim's “a history of us” series, the volume titled, “war, terrible war 1855-1865”: the southerners who opposed slavery did not speak up loudly and, as long as slavery stayed in the south, most northerners were happy to forget about it. Southern fears of losing control of the federal government to antislavery forces, and northern fears that the slave power already controlled the government gettysburg is considered the turning point of the american civil war by some historians others argue the south was doomed after antietam in 1862. It contains bumper stickers, literature and t-shirts i collected while researching confederates in the attic, a book about civil war memory in the south constructed a potent ideology—the lost cause—that romanticized plantation life and cast the war as a noble, doomed defense of southern freedom and.

was the south doomed to lose the civil war A comparison of the south's experience with defeat and america's emerging response to its loss of the war in vietnam may be helpful such a comparison need not ignore the substantial differences between the civil and vietnam wars the former was a domestic conflict, fought only on american soil.
Was the south doomed to lose the civil war
Rated 4/5 based on 18 review

2018.